The short answer: Yes, you can use olive oil in desserts. Replace butter with about three-quarters as much olive oil (3/4 cup for every 1 cup of butter) in recipes that use melted butter, like cakes, muffins and brownies. Greek sweets such as melomakarona and semolina halva have long been made with olive oil.
Olive oil cakes are everywhere right now, and a drizzle of olive oil over ice cream has become a favorite restaurant dessert. In Greece, none of this is new. Greek families have made sweets with olive oil for generations — partly because during Lent and other fasting periods, butter and dairy are traditionally left out, and olive oil takes their place.
Why olive oil works in sweets
- Moist cakes that stay moist. Oil stays liquid at room temperature, so olive oil cakes keep a tender crumb for days.
- Flavor, not just fat. A good extra virgin olive oil brings fruity, green notes that pair beautifully with citrus, nuts, chocolate and honey.
- A dairy-free option. Many traditional Greek sweets are naturally free of butter and milk.
How to swap butter for olive oil
A reliable rule of thumb: use about 3/4 the amount of olive oil. For 1 cup of butter, use 3/4 cup of olive oil; for one stick (8 tablespoons), use 6 tablespoons.
- Works best in: recipes that call for melted butter or oil — cakes, quick breads, muffins, brownies.
- Doesn’t work well in: recipes that cream soft butter with sugar, like many cookies, or that cut cold butter into flour, like biscuits and pie crust. Liquid oil can’t hold air or make flaky layers the same way.
Which oil for which dessert
| Dessert | Our pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Cakes, muffins, cookies | Extra Virgin 500 mL | Smooth and fruity, lets citrus and vanilla shine |
| Chocolate cake and brownies | Early Harvest | Its bold, peppery notes stand up to dark chocolate |
| Raw drizzles: ice cream, yogurt, fruit | Early Harvest | You taste every bit of its green, peppery character |
Four ways to try it this week
Vanilla ice cream, olive oil and salt
The Italians call it gelato con olio e sale. Scoop a good vanilla ice cream, drizzle a teaspoon of Early Harvest over the top and finish with a pinch of flaky salt. Sweet, creamy, fruity and peppery all at once. Add a shot of hot espresso and you have an olive oil affogato.
Greek yogurt, honey and olive oil
Thick Greek yogurt, a spoonful of honey, a few walnuts and a thin thread of olive oil. Breakfast or dessert — it works for both.
Melomakarona
Greece’s favorite Christmas cookies are made with olive oil, orange and warm spices, then soaked in honey syrup and topped with chopped walnuts. Soft, fragrant and impossible to eat just one. With the holidays coming, this is the one to bake.
Semolina halva
A classic fasting-day dessert, often remembered by its ratio: 1 cup olive oil, 2 cups semolina, 3 cups sugar, 4 cups water. The semolina is toasted golden in the oil, then a cinnamon syrup is poured in and it’s stirred until thick. Many families add raisins, almonds or walnuts and serve it in slices, dusted with cinnamon.
Craving olive oil with your coffee too?
That trend has its own story. Read Olive oil in coffee: worth trying?
Questions people also ask
Will my cake taste like olive oil?
A smooth extra virgin olive oil adds a light fruitiness that pairs well with citrus and vanilla. A bold, peppery oil is more noticeable, which works well with dark chocolate.
Can you use olive oil instead of butter in cookies?
Not in cookies made by creaming soft butter with sugar, because oil can’t hold air the same way. Cookies designed for oil, like Greek melomakarona, work beautifully.
What is olive oil on ice cream called?
In Italy it’s called gelato con olio e sale: vanilla ice cream with a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil and a pinch of flaky salt.
Sources
- How to substitute olive oil for butter in baking, California Olive Ranch
- Thing or not a thing: gelato con olio e sale, Melbourne Food and Wine